Globally, osteoporosis is a significant and
growing public health problem. The greatest increase in fractures,
by far, will occur in Asia, including India. By 2050, one out
of every two fractures worldwide will occur in Asia. In India,
awareness of osteoporosis is low, since there has been relatively
little effort to publicize the disease. Various small-scale
surveys indicate that awareness of the disease in the urban
population is about 10%-15%. A larger survey to assess public
attitude and physician awareness is required - India will
be one of 18 countries included in a major IOF research study
How Fragile is Our Future, which will be completed by January
2006.
It is clear that a large-scale public awareness effort is
required to bring the issue of osteoporosis to the attention
of individuals, health care professionals, and government
health officials.
Osteoporosis is serious, but it is a ‘good’ disease
to promote because people can take steps to prevent the disease
(to a certain extent through proper nutrition, exercise and
lifestyle choices), it is easy to diagnose, and many treatments
are available which can reduce the risk of fracture by up
to 50%.
With increasing longevity of the Indian population, it is
now being realized, that, like in the west, osteoporotic fractures
are a major cause of morbidity and mortality in the elderly.
Osteoporosis is a silent disease, reflected only in a low
bone density, till a fracture occurs. Much in the manner that
asymptomatic conditions like hypertension and dyslipidemia
predispose to stroke and myocardial infarction respectively,
a low bone density (reflecting poor bone health) predisposes
to osteoporotic fractures. The fracture prevention strategy
consists of increasing peak bone mass in the growing years
and reducing subsequent bone loss throughout life.
Although solid epidemiological data are lacking, hospital
data suggest that hip fractures are common in India. Available
data suggest that:
- Osteoporosis is prevalent in India.
- Osteoporotic fractures occur more commonly in Indian males
than females
- Osteoporotic fractures occur 10-20 years earlier than
in the west.
While these are reasonable conclusions, we must keep in
mind that there is no epidemiological data on fracture prevalence,
although most clinicians would agree that hip fractures are
common. The male female ratio may be distorted because of
men being more likely to be brought for hospital care. The
lower peak age as compared to the west may be simply linked
to a shorter life span, as also to the inclusion of traumatic/non-fragility
fractures in the analysis. Perhaps it is best to simply conclude
that osteoporotic fractures are common in India and occur
in both sexes.
Dual energy X Ray absorptiometry (DXA) technology, the gold
standard for diagnosing osteoporosis by measuring bone density,
became available in India only in 1997 at the Sanjay Gandhi
Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow. Subsequently
several other machines became available and the last 3 years
have seen their number grow to almost 140. However, these
are still mostly localized to the larger cities- Delhi and
Bombay alone account for more than 30 of these installations.
Thus while certain segments of the Indian population do have
access to diagnosis and treatment, these techniques remain
inaccessible to the majority of Indians. Overall the BMD at
all sites seems to be 5-15% lower than Caucasians. However,
there are differences in BMD between different centres, and
a very recent study involving healthy subjects presenting
for a preventive health check in Delhi has suggested that
BMD differences with western populations may be minimal, and
could be related to the smaller skeletal size of Indians.
The issue of appropriate BMD normative data for Indians remains
open. There is need to study the BMD- fracture relationship
in Indians (fracture threshold) to determine the ideal normative
data for Indian population. If Indians fracture at the same
level of BMD as Caucasians, there would be no reason to have
separate normative data for Indians.
Recent data indicates a high prevalence of vitamin D deficiency
in urban Indians, despite availability of abundant sunshine.
Studies have shown that the majority of urban office workers
and hospital staff have moderate to severe vitamin D deficiency,
which is usually asymptomatic. Inadequate calcium intake was
proposed as an additional factor contributing to the low BMD.
Thus low vitamin D levels (and low calcium intakes) could
also be major contributing factors to poor bone health and
osteoporosis in India.
Poor sunlight exposure, skin pigmentation and a vitamin D
deficient diet are some obvious causes for this finding. Atmospheric
pollution has also been suggested as a contributor to vitamin
D deficiency in children from Delhi. The spectrum of vitamin
D deficiency in India extends from asymptomatic deficiency,
to frank osteomalacia, a crippling disorder. Recent data also
suggest that a healthy lifestyle (diet, exercise and sunlight
exposure) can have a major positive impact on the bone metabolism
and bone health of Indians.
Overall, it appears that typical urban (“white collar”)
Indians have poor bone health, and osteoporosis is common
in India. However, adequate calcium intake, regular physical
exercise and sunlight exposure can go along way in improving
Indians’ bone health and potentially reducing fracture
risk. There is thus an urgent need for spreading public awareness
in this regard, particularly about the benefits of sunlight
exposure.
Most current therapies for osteoporosis, like the bisphosphonates
risedronate and alendronate, raloxifene, and teriparatide
(PTH) are now available in India. Awareness about appropriate
use of these agents, as well as proper interpretation of bone
densitometric findings remains major issues. Cost, also, remains
a factor to be tackled. There has been some improvement in
the reimbursement and insurance facilities for these agents,
but sustained effort will be required to bring osteoporosis
diagnosis and treatment into the mainstream of healthcare.
|